The Elders

Guest blog
,

In pictures: Bethlehem under threat

“No one has tried to tell the story of my town beyond the stereotypes of the Nativity or the brutality of military occupation.”

Ahead of the Pope’s visit to Bethlehem this week, Palestinian filmmaker Leila Sansour warns that the city's tradition of peaceful coexistence is in danger of vanishing completely.

2007-2008: A view of Bethlehem behind Israel’s separation wall.

Historically a peaceful, prosperous town in which different religious communities lived and thrived, Bethlehem has suffered under Israeli occupation. Many residents have left, rather than live under increasing restrictions, hardship and isolation.

1940s: A wedding in an old Ottoman mansion in Bethlehem.

The late 19th and early 20th century saw an enormous economic boom in Bethlehem and many very opulent buildings were built at the time. This is one of them. They all used to be homes of wealthy families, but this building now houses Bethlehem University.

1970s: The Hotel Management Department was one of the most vibrant at Bethlehem University – 72 per cent of Bethlehem’s economy depends on tourism.

The department is still there, but is not as ambitious as it used to be.

Circa 1960: A Bethlehem picnic.

Circa 1960: St Joseph's School, Bethlehem.

2009: In this picture, I am standing on a roof in the heart of the old city of Bethlehem. In the distance you see the settlement of Har Homa; immediately beyond it lies Jerusalem.

Just a few years ago, Har Homa was a pine forest (see inset, circa 1988). The hill’s Arabic name was Jabal Abu Ghneim. The rapid expansion of Har Homa and adjacent settlements – which has happened since the 1993 Oslo Accords – is a very disturbing development because Israel is closing the last remaining geographical link between Bethlehem and Jerusalem.

2004: Bethlehemites gather in Nativity Square, calling on Israel to release Palestinian prisoners.

This protest takes place annually on Prisoners Day, when people come out to demand the release of their family members.

2005: People living in Bethlehem need military permits to cross to the other side of the wall for work, medical services and to visit family.

Israel has a quota of around 3,000 work permits for the district of Bethlehem, which is home to around 200,000 residents. Most of the people pictured would have been queueing from 3am in order to reach their work at 8am or 9am in the morning.

This area in the northern part of Bethlehem used to be very affluent. It contains a shrine, ‘Rachel's tomb’, which is considered the third holiest site in Judaism as well as being revered in Christianity and Islam.

It was always part of Bethlehem, but the separation wall has been used to annex the tomb to Israel, leaving the area devastated. You can read more about it in this UN report.

Many ancient cities have vanished. We read about them in history books without giving much thought to how the world could have been different had they stayed with us. In this instance, the subject is Bethlehem, a city that is vanishing in front of our eyes. Does it matter?

This is the question I have been asking myself since Christmas 2004, when I embarked on a film that was meant to chronicle the changes taking place in my hometown. Israel had just started building a wall that today confines Bethlehem to less than 13 per cent of its original territory, a development that threatens to drive out all of its Christian population.

I have always known that Bethlehem is a unique place but it was always difficult to put it into words. Despite its global fame, no one has tried to tell the story of my town beyond the stereotypes of the Nativity or the brutality of military occupation. Yet Bethlehem does have another story, and understanding it is key to a meaningful engagement with the politics of the Middle East.

A wealthy town with a global outlook

It wasn’t until very recently that I discovered an account that supports my long-held belief about Bethlehem’s unusual pedigree. The study was carried out by a British historian called Jacob Norris. His research reveals an extraordinary tale of a humble town going global, not just because of its biblical brand but also because of the initiative and acumen displayed by its inhabitants.

Close to Jerusalem, yet tucked away from the direct pressures of the Ottoman administration that ruled Palestine from 1516 to 1917, Bethlehem was able to forge an identity of its own aided by the Franciscan monks whose mission in Bethlehem, as in other parts of Palestine, was to guard the Christian holy sites. Sensing the fragile nature of their welcome in a region ruled by a Muslim caliphate, the Franciscans sought to strengthen their presence in the Holy Land by forging closer links with Bethlehem’s native Christian community. They opened schools and started workshops where they produced artefacts branded “Made in the Holy Land” – and Christian Europe could not get enough.

At first, the main beneficiaries of this growing industry were the Franciscans themselves. But as early as the 18th century, Bethlehemites would go above the heads of the Franciscans to forge their own trade routes, travelling and establishing offices as far away as Kiev, America and the Philippines. They turned their trade into a multimillion dollar industry that would bring Bethlehem enormous wealth and, more importantly, a global outlook.

A model of coexistence

Now, looking back at the 1970s, the time that I was growing up, I recognise the privileges we enjoyed: the privilege of wealth; the privilege of an excellent education, which was almost universal in Bethlehem; and, more importantly, the privilege of an easy attitude towards difference.

Bethlehem was diverse not just because it was a top address for Christian missionaries and pilgrims throughout the ages, but because its own population was a blend of Christians and Muslims who have made a happy marriage in a city where they could share the spiritual space as well as the wealth that came with it. Muslims venerate Jesus as a prophet, and pilgrimage to the Nativity church has always been common among the Muslims of Palestine.

Bethlehem today: the impact of occupation

Today, 47 years after the Israeli occupation of the town, the picture in Bethlehem is very different. The isolation of the city and the economic hardship brought about by the wall and the expansion of Israeli settlements means that the vast majority of Bethlehem’s original population have now left their hometown believing that it could no longer offer them a future. Many have lost their hard-earned, privately owned lands to settlements which now number 40. The wall has confiscated most of Bethlehem’s agricultural fields and landmarks, leaving no space for the city to expand or even build basic amenities. The vast majority of those who have left the town, like my own family, are Christian. They constituted most of the wealthy urban population, having been better positioned to benefit from the tourist trade.

Many international agencies, including the UN, now speak with alarm about the changing face of Bethlehem. Having worked on my film for the past ten years, I have documented these changes with much sadness, amassing an archive that tells the story of this loss. The most striking experience, I find, is the role of Western countries. Millions of dollars are being spent today in the Middle East to establish democratic institutions that may or may not succeed. But very little endeavour is made to preserve model cities, the vibrant and real democratic institutions, finely moulded through centuries of experience and tested formulas.

Bethlehem is one such an institution and it needs international attention.

Leila Sansour is a filmmaker and the founder and Executive Director of Open Bethlehem, a non-governmental foundation established to promote and protect the life and heritage of the city of Bethlehem. Her latest film, Open Bethlehem, will be released in the UK ahead of Christmas 2014.

All photographs published by permission of Planet Bethlehem, with thanks to Sari Khoury and the Centre for Cultural Heritage Preservation. They were gathered as part of the Open Bethlehem multimedia project.

Views expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily represent those of The Elders or The Elders Foundation.

Comments

Please read our moderation policy before commenting

  • All comments posted on www.theElders.org will be moderated before publication.
  • In making comments, please be constructive and treat others with respect.
  • Comments containing hate speech, obscenity, inflammatory statements or accusations, personal attacks, discriminatory or abusive language will not be posted.
  • Links: Please do link to other relevant sites and articles to enrich the debate. Please do not link to inappropriate or offensive websites or use signature links in your post.
The Elders are independent global leaders, brought together by Nelson Mandela, who offer their collective influence and experience to support peace building, help address major causes of human suffering and promote the shared interests of humanity.

Sign up to receive monthly newsletters from The Elders.

We will occasionally send you other special updates and news, but we'll never share your email address with third parties.

Visit the archive to see our past newsletters.

The Elders website uses cookies. Click here to accept the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy when visiting this site.